Artificial Intelligence in Health Care: Keeping Human Dignity at the Centre

The W.F. Mitchell Bioethics Seminar was held in Pylypchuk Hall with Dr. Anito Ho, a bioethics professor at the University of British Columbia and the University of California, San Francisco, and Vice President in Ethics for Common Spirit Health (California). Dr. Ho’s presentation, Exploring the Power of AI in Health Care Through a Relational Lens was given to 104 people in person and more than 100 people joined online.  

From identifying patients at risk of serious illness to helping physicians spend less time on paperwork, AI has the potential to improve both efficiency and patient care. However, Dr. Ho cautioned against what she calls “AI solutionism,” the belief that technology can solve every problem. Just because AI can predict which patients might miss appointments, for example, doesn’t mean it can tell us why. A patient may face transportation challenges, financial difficulties or other barriers that an algorithm cannot fully capture. Are we using technology to address these challenges, or simply to make the healthcare system run more efficiently?

Dr. Ho urged health care providers to consider how AI may influence decision-making, patient autonomy and the relationships between patients and healthcare providers. Although algorithms may appear objective, they are only as reliable as the information used to develop them. Dr. Ho shared examples of how AI systems can unintentionally reinforce existing inequalities, particularly when the data fails to reflect the experiences of diverse populations. She also explored the use of AI to predict when a patient may be approaching the end of life. While this information could support earlier conversations about palliative care, it also raises difficult questions. How should such predictions be communicated? Is the patient ready to receive that information? How do we preserve hope and compassion during an already vulnerable time? These are decisions that require more than data. They require clinical judgment, sensitivity and an understanding of the individual person. As AI becomes more integrated into health care, we must also consider whether patients and healthcare professionals have a meaningful voice in how these technologies are used.

For Catholic healthcare organizations, these questions are closely connected to our commitment to human dignity and the common good. Drawing on the teachings of Pope Leo XIV, Dr. Ho emphasized that AI, regardless of how sophisticated it becomes, must remain a tool that serves humanity. Its success should not be measured by efficiency or cost savings alone, but also by whether it improves patient experiences, supports healthcare professionals and promotes equitable access to care. This requires thoughtful oversight, ongoing evaluation and meaningful involvement from the people most affected by these technologies. Dr. Ho’s presentation offered plenty to reflect on as AI continues to evolve. How can we embrace innovation without losing the compassion, mercy and personal connection that define good health care? Perhaps the most important question is not what AI can do for us, but how we can use it to better care for one another.

The seminar was made possible by the W.F. Mitchell Endowment which is stewarded by the St. Paul’s Hospital Foundation. William F. Mitchell was a Saskatoon business man, who recognized the value of ethical reflection both in the business world and in health care.

The full presentation has been recorded and is available upon request. Please contact mary.heilman@emmanuelhealth.ca